Sunday, July 13, 2008

Do lefties have an advantage in sports?

It is a sheer coincidence the subject of this post and the previous one is LEFT. I promise you this time its not politics, but on southpaws in sports. The real inspiration for this post is a sports column in yahoo which appeared a week ago. It is about the unfair advantage the lefties get in baseball and was articulately written by an engineering professor from Washington Univ, St.Louis. In short he says, a left hander pitcher and batter both have an advantage and if you follow the game very closely you will notice the same. So a coach should always be aware of this fact and he is usually and sometimes you can see a pitching change just to bring in a southpaw even though a right handed pitcher continues to pitch well.

I have always wondered if the same is applicable in other sports too and yes it is. I was just trying to dissect Federer's Wimbledon loss to Nadal and this fact stood out. I'm sure people would have discussed this on numerous occasions and certainly John McEnroe a lefty will not buy this argument. According to the article, 10% of general public are left handed. So to win a championship in tennis, one needs to win 7 matches and the probability says roughly a right handed player has to face a lefty if he needs to win the championship. And so is the case for Federer who typically faces Nadal in the finals. Roger after facing 6 right handed players, has to adjust himself to face Nadal, while Nadal reaches the finals playing 6 right handed players and hence is a cushion to him.

This is an advantage only when the player's competence level is very close, otherwise it will be completely masked by sheer dominance of a higher competent player. This has been the case in the past. Based on the outcome of this year's Wimbledon this is one factor which clearly played a role in the first two sets, when Nadal was clearly forcing Federer to play backhand, while Nadal plays forehand. If you would have watched the first two sets of the game all of Nadal's serve targeted Federer's backhand. This was a clear strategy on Nadal's part just taking advantage of him being a lefty. I'm not sure how many of you agree this, but this is clear advantage for the lefties just not in tennis alone.

2 comments:

Rambler said...

Let us think of it this way... Lefties are living in a world fashioned for the righties. So at the end of the day even though left is their best side they have higher development of their right side as well.... Which is not so for the right handed people.. Most right handed people can't even throw a stone with their left hands. On the contrary the southpaws are mostly ambidextrous and hence are stronger on the field and have better balance....

Anonymous said...

You cud add the case of Brian Lara, Mathew Hayden, Gary Sobers, Mark Taylor, Sanath Jayasurya, Chris Gayle etc etc making triple centuries ...